Image of a neighbourhood in Mumbai, India.

Source: Suraj Tomer (Unsplash)

By Fani Kantzavelos, Staff Writer

Every Tuesday at 8 a.m., I find myself among 23 other students on the basement floor of the Munk Graduate School of Global Affairs. The reason for our convening in the early morning: Professor Joseph Wong and his course, Global Innovation. Every week, our class is assigned a reading with a theme, aiming to understand its content, dissect its meaning, and hear each other’s perspectives. We discuss what the reading means to us, to its broader context, and, most importantly, to global innovation. 

On September 24th, our discussion was centred around Katherine Boo’s literary non-fiction novel, Behind the Beautiful Forevers: Life, Death and Hope in a Mumbai Undercity. Boo is an American journalist writing about the lives of the inhabitants of one of Mumbai’s slums, Annawadi. She depicts the daily routines of around fifteen characters, who illustrate how Muslims and Hindus interact within a small social environment, how corruption is the means to the end of improving one’s living standard, and how, despite every single promise made to those who live in the slum, they are fated to the hand that life has dealt them. 

Professor Wong always begins by asking for our initial thoughts and impressions on the reading. Usually, those who answer the first question each highlight a different aspect that stood out to them the most. Yet, on that September morning, there was a resounding sentiment: Boo made us want to put the book down halfway through. Her writing captured a raw struggle that we had never been exposed to, that evoked a profound emotional reaction. 

As our discussion progressed, Professor Wong asked us if the novel would have been better if, in Boo’s place, an Indian individual had authored her narrative. I remember one of our classmates noting that if an Indian author undertook the struggle of investigating the life of a Mumbai slum, it would be seen as a complaint, not a brutally honest testimony. At that moment, I remember strongly disagreeing that a book’s perspective could be seen as an unfound protest. I even made a point later on about the autobiography of a North Korean defector, Every Falling Star, written by Sungju Lee. I was of the opinion that the author’s autobiographical experience was not being seen as a complaint of his upbringing, but a hard truth of the conditions he was brought up in. 

When I discussed this point with another classmate later on, who happens to be from Mumbai, she spoke to me about a novel similar to Boo’s, White Tiger, written by Aravind Aniga, whose book was ill-received in India. The novel’s plot circles around a boy who grows up in rural India and eventually finds work with a wealthy family and kills his employer to escape his poverty and becomes wealthy himself. Aniga, through his protagonist, highlights how India’s economic growth disadvantages the poor and propels the rich, leading people to take extreme measures, such as murder, to overcome their socioeconomic oppression. 

White Tiger, despite its literary masterfulness, was seen as a complaint, a sort of unjustified whining about India’s rapid economic growth in the past decades, stemming from a popular unwillingness to accept their resonance with the protagonist’s struggle and desperation. Ultimately, I was wrong in my initial judgment.

Compared to White Tiger’s reception in India and in the West, where readers also were left surprised by the rawness of the novel’s narrative, Boo evokes sympathy from her audience for the mere fact that her perspective is that of her characters. Anagi’s narrative emphasizes the extreme measures someone is forced to take to reach economic prosperity, a far-fetched reality, insinuating that only through violence can one achieve financial stability. Boo’s characters, contrastingly, follow their habitual ways and are trapped in their slum from start to finish, offering a reality that seems plausible, a progression of the characters that incentivizes innovators to want to invest in Annawadi and every other Annawadi.

The most important part of our class conversation didn’t lie in our analysis of the characters or the tragedy of their problems, but the very fact that Boo made us focus on Annawadi, and every other setting like Annawadi. Yes, Boo emphasizes the vicious cycle of socioeconomic inequality, religious tensions, and the contemplation of death as an escape from life. Yes, we need to understand these issues, especially in a global innovation class, where our goal is to comprehend how to innovate in light of these problems. But the most crucial aspect here is the fact that we have a forum to discuss the picture Boo paints and listen to others’ perceptions of that picture. 

At the same time, we shouldn’t discount accounts like Anagi’s, which are more extreme, but reflect a picture seen by locals, whether they want to admit that it is true or not. We need to be uncomfortable with the accounts that pursue this so-called comfort that innovation creates. Otherwise, how can we truly innovate? How can we come up with novel solutions if we are not informed of people’s experiences? 

The shift of the focus of the conversation to perception and how it permeates an audience again highlights the importance of discussing these issues and how they are received by society and those who innovate within its environment. If I did not express myself in class, if I was not as invested as my classmates were in Boo’s novel, I would have limited myself to my perspective, I would have believed in an innovation uninformed by people’s reception of accounts of issues they are surrounded by. 

Boo proves that Behind the Beautiful Forevers lies a combination of experience and perspective that needs to be discussed. We need to innovate in the most considerate and skilled ways we know to create a meaningful impact toward eradicating society’s troubles, either with Professor Wong as moderator in MUN 100, or in our daily lives. 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *