
Image source: Chelsea Beck/Gizmodo
The implications of gene doping on sportsmanship
By Emma Guo, Staff Writer
Most young athletes dream of becoming an Olympic champion, but what does it take to achieve it? Is it possible to find a loophole, such as using genetic editing technology?
Low-level sports start with a high diversity of morphological features. However, particular morphologies become more prominent in elite levels. For instance, professional gymnasts tend to have smaller statues. Interestingly, recent studies have found that elite athletes have common genes related to greater muscular endurance, indicating that genetics may play a key role in one’s athletic success.
Take Michael Phelps: he’s practically won the genetic lottery. Phelps seems to have the perfect physiology for a swimmer with a double-jointed chest, a genetic advantage to experience less muscle fatigue, and above-average wingspan and lung capacity. What about Caster Semenya and Dutee Chand, female athletes barred from competing internationally due to a genetic advantage that increases their testosterone production? If Semenya and Chand’s situations were considered unfair, why was there nothing done about Phelps and his several genetic advantages? Is there some way we can level the playing field in athletics without necessitating actions against athletes, such as disqualification?
With advancements in biotechnology, genome editing is a possible answer. While it is primarily used in treatments for cancer and muscular dystrophy, its non-therapeutic use has been acknowledged in the form of “gene doping” in athletes.
Playing Fair with Gene Doping?
Erythropoietin (EPO), a hormone that regulates red blood cell production, has been widely available since the late 1980s in the form of recombinant human EPO (rHuEPO). The use of rHuEPO induces the production of more red blood cells and thus boosts oxygen delivery to muscles. Athletes would inject rHuEPO into their bloodstream to increase endurance in aerobic exercise. This was widely known as difficult-to-detect “blood doping” (now known as gene doping).
However, the World Anti-Doping Agency (WADA) banned the use of any gene doping in 2003 due to the risks it imposes on an athlete’s health. The initial uses of rHuEPO were to treat patients with illnesses with low red blood cell counts. However, its use in healthy athletes can deplete naturally occurring EPO, leading to long-term irreversible effects. Other fatal side effects in healthy individuals involve issues with the cardiovascular system, such as heart failure.
Gene therapy in itself is still at an experimental stage, where many treatments are part of clinical trials. But what if one day, gene doping becomes safe for use in athletes? We already have seen high-tech training methods, such as altitude training, propagate through the world of athletics. If gene doping becomes widespread, what would be its implications on what athletics stands for?
The Implications of Gene Doping
Many reasons argue against the legalization of gene doping. For example, gene doping enables the erasure of meritocracy, allowing athletes to succeed without putting much work in. Take the example of high altitude training, a method used to stimulate EPO production. Rather than sitting back and waiting for the rHuEPO to kick in, athletes are enduring many weeks of living at high altitudes. Those who use gene doping could expend less energy while reaping the same benefits.
Yet counterarguments can be made that sports are never 100% fully meritocratic because of people like Phelps, Semenya, and Chand. Their genetics put them at an advantage over other athletes in the same way that gene doping would. However, it is still not impossible to become an established athlete even when you are genetically disadvantaged – there are rare exceptions. For instance, Yuzuru Hanyu suffers from asthma which has plagued him throughout his skating career. Despite these difficulties, he won multiple world titles and is a two-time Olympic champion.
Legalizing gene doping would further exacerbate the socioeconomic divide between countries and only enable certain countries to access gene doping resources. A potential arms race where athletes overuse doping could negatively impact their health, such as increasing the risk of cancer. Its legalization would also revive the conversation of genetically engineered fetuses and whether it is ethical to alter a child’s genome before they are born.
TL;DR
Athletics is plagued with genetic and environmental advantages. For example, the high levels of EPO found in people who reside at high altitudes contribute to increased red blood cell production. However, there is not much we can do about this. Although gene doping could potentially aid in levelling the playing field of less genetically advantaged athletes, there appears to be too many health risks and negative social implications. As such, to achieve Olympic gold, you may have to first win the genetic lottery while having a hard-core work ethic.
